Hi all. The intent of this post is to spread extremely important information from Royale High's community on Twitter for those that do not participate there. This is a long post, but it is very important information - please read!
**PLEASE ALSO READ REPLIES!** Additional EXTREMELY IMPORTANT info is discussed in there and it is really disgusting what happened in Launce's stream this evening. This is deplorable behaviour.
Royale High Wiki is an objective resource; our articles aim to be without bias, so we do not avoid documenting just because something is not good about RH. Our staff team, however, is very much against the ongoing exploitation and disrespect that Royale High has shown for a long time, and especially finds the recent incidents deplorable. We would like to share this so that our community is just as aware of what is going on.
If you can, share the information with others. It is highly important that Royale High, and especially Barbie (callmehbob), takes accountability for these extremely disrespectful and harmful things they have been encouraging and practicing for a long time, along with recent incidents.
The only way this will be heard is if people speak out and stop giving money and metrics to Royale High (i.e. stop playing for now), and the only way that will happen is if more people know about it.
Some context as to what started this - Performative activism
The Valentines 2022 event contains a small section dedicated to Black History Month (BHM). It mostly showcases images of the creations of black creators in the Royale High community. This stand area is an update to last year's, swapping out/adding to some of the artists, and including a NPC of imkatt, a black artist and activist in Royale High's community.
An important difference from the BHM area (and the Lunar New Year area) from last year is that Royale High contracted creators to help ensure accuracy and advise on ideas. For BHM, imkatt along with other black creators and activists in RH community were contracted.
A number of the Lunar New Year suggestions were added, but many of the BHM elements were not. In fact, a part 2 to the Black History Month section of the event was apparently planned... and subsequently cancelled, by Barbie.
imkatt and TechnoTatum (another contracted advisor) spoke out on Feb 19 about the incident surrounding this. This includes an element that makes a horrific notation of that the addition appears to have been performative activism - which is absolutely not okay for Royale High to do.
A lot of discussion ongoing based on this, including the lack of payment for the contractors, went on, and the current discussion on Twitter surrounds asking Barbie to take responsibility and accountability for disrespecting black voices and other POC (people of color), and using Royale High to profit off of them.
Relevant tweets (CONTENT WARNING: swear words are in some of these tweets, do read w/ caution if that makes you uncomfortable):
https://twitter.com/TechnoTatum/status/1494930349498974212
https://twitter.com/imkatt_/status/1495053358889111554
https://twitter.com/imkatt_/status/1495455075946450946
Artists are not being compensated
A separate issue was actually something I had brought up at the beginning of January, personally. You may know that Royale High takes submissions for faces, hair textures, etc. but are you aware that they profit from these? And while they make money from this work, the people who made it... don't?
Sadly, for years, Royale High has taken advantage of and exploited over 400 artists to submit free work that Royale High profits from. They see no payment, no compensation. Only exposure... and exposure doesn't pay the bills.
Yes, it's over 400. See this document for a list:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/15HcyYpgqpmBBpv53QoctCS0V-DAxGc9nwgq70BYMn1s/edit#gid=0
This has come up again with these recent Twitter revelations, partially due to that the BHM contractors were barely paid anything for their work (only a small amount of in-game currency), but also because it is yet another thing Barbie needs to take charge over.
Other games on Roblox that take submissions for assets, such as Mermaid Life, pay DevEx rate Robux amounts for them. And they also commission artists. Royale High does not. They simply take the submissions and do not give anything back directly. Only 2D clothing sees any pay, and indirectly so.
An important detail is that a large amount of these artists are MINORS - they often do not know better, that they think exposure will help. They don't even get exposure really, though. They need money, not exposure.
RH did actually used to tip artists back in 2018. Once more artists came around, they stopped. I hope I don't need to explain how backwards that is.
If RH can't afford or doesn't want to pay, they shouldn't be accepting these assets. Full stop.
Royale High is one of the top experiences on Roblox and makes thousands daily; they can afford to pay their artists. So why aren't they? Why are they instead just profiting from their free work? It's yet another thing Barbie needs to be held accountable for.
Relevant tweets (CONTENT WARNING: some replies by others in these tweets contain swear words, be careful if that makes you uncomfortable):
https://twitter.com/Karasuneth/status/1477764816077008902
https://twitter.com/Karasuneth/status/1477733088331509764
https://twitter.com/Karasuneth/status/1477764816077008902
Other persistent issues in Royale High
This will be a quick list of other problems Royale High has not fixed as I don't want to make this thread too long;
- Offensive or misuse-able Sunset Island themes (only some examples) that should be removed:
Egyptian: There is a lot of misinformation on "Egyptian fashion" and is culturally appropriating.
Genderbend: Genderbending is transphobic because it is a form of transgender fetishization. It is also enbyphobic as it suggests a gender binary that can be swapped between, and conflicts with gender non-conforming individuals..
Ugliest outfit ever: While mostly known for people misusing POC hairstyles and the hijab, generally it encourages discriminating against groups and looks in general and has no place.
Southern Belle: The style encouraged by the theme is referencing a fashion style used by rich white people that owned slaves in US history.
- Names of certain black hair styles: Many black and POC hairstyles in RH use stereotypical names for black people and POC, instead of describing the hair like other hairstyles. They should be changed.
- Names of certain pride flag themed hair colours: Some of the original hair colour options themed around pride flags are offensive. They should be changed.
The one for the pansexual flag can be interpreted as insisting pansexuality is made up.
The one for the asexual flag can be interpreted as a reference to a stereotype for asexuals.
One of the colours for the transgender flag has a variant name that is the same as a slur for transgender people, especially trans men.
- The Hijab is not programmed properly to prevent people wearing offensive clothing with it, or bangs. When wearing a hijab, it is inappropriate to show skin other than hands and face, and hair must not be visible. This should be fixed.
- DotD items should not be categorised under Halloween, and the Celebration Sombrero doesn't have a culturally accurate design and should be fixed.
- The pride flag display in Diamond Beach has all the flags upside down (vertically symmetrical flags are technically correct still), and uses an offensive flag for pansexuals (the orange, green, and yellow one). Turn them the right way and remove the offensive flag.
Taking advantage of minorities and young artists is extremely messed up
I think this doesn't need much explanation. Performative activism is disgusting and only adding a BHM section for the gold star of "we ran a BHM event and other games didn't" is a mess. Not paying hundreds of artists while you make money from their art shows extremely bad morals.
It has been years that Royale High has done this. It is time for Barbie to take responsibility and accountability for what she has encouraged. Change needs to happen.
I will note, that if Royale High fixes these things, does not mean Royale High would be better and okay to play. Royale High has shown for a long, long time what their true colours are - this is simply the community finally noticing. Some of us, including myself, used to have more contact with the leads, and we let them know of these problems in the past; they dismissed or brushed it off. Royale High knew there were issues. Barbie knew. They all did nothing. If they do something now, it's only because more than a small group of people told them to fix it, and it'll just be because they want you back to not lose out.
Don't be eager to come back if you boycott. This isn't a one day or one week thing. This persists until something is done for the better. And even so, perhaps it is time to move on from RH.
What can I do?
- Make others aware of this situation: This information is currently mainly localized on Twitter. It is important that more people hear about this so RH and Barbie are held accountable and that less people are inclined to play. Share the news to other platforms and communities for RH (please respect their rules!) and let your friends know.
- Do not play RH, or at least do not give them money: The biggest hit to RH to reduce their impact is to reduce incentive and metrics. Not playing is one less person on the player count, one less person generating money for them. If you must, don't give RH any money directly; don't buy any diamonds or passes.
- Try out & support alternative games: Many players continue on RH since there is no major alternative. However, there are smaller ones; help them grow and spread the word. Here's a list: https://twitter.com/imkatt_/status/1495457212013199362 -- Some of these games are indev and can't be played, but you can support the devs instead to help encourage development.
- Review the #OwnUpBarbie tag on Twitter: You do not need a Twitter account to look at it. It contains a lot of creators speaking out about extended issues with Royale High. Note that this tag is mainly regarding disrespect of black voices, performative activism, and cancelling BHM part 2; it's not intended for the other issues. CONTENT WARNING: some tweets may contain swear words. https://twitter.com/search?q=%23ownupbarbie
As said previously, Royale High Wiki doesn't support what Royale High is doing right now morally. We are an objective resource, and our staff does not support exploitation or performative activism.
Do note that our forums and community (along with our Discord) aren't exclusive to RH fans, and we are open to all discussion. Even if you quit RH, you're free to still participate and talk to our communities as long as you follow the rules. Most of our staff haven't actually played RH for a long time, or ever, even if we're here. So you don't have to necessarily quit the wiki if you quit the game.
Feel free to extend any discussion or questions under this thread for the time being. We aren't necessarily prohibiting separate threads about it, but we would prefer most of it to go under the one so it's easier to moderate. Thanks.